Social Contract

Thomas Hobbes, a 17th-century philosopher and author of Leviathan, argued that humans are driven by self-interest and the instinct for survival, which can be inherently self-destructive. To curtail our tendency to drift towards chaos and early death, he proposed his social contract theory, where we sacrifice some freedoms to the state in exchange for safety, peace, and security.

Hobbes recognized that surrendering freedoms may lead to tyranny. He said that if the state becomes oppressive, the social contract is broken, and citizens are no longer bound to submit to its authority. He argued that the contract is rational and valid only as long as the benefits outweigh the costs.

Thomas Jefferson used a similar argument in the Declaration of Independence, stating: “That whenever any Form of Government becomes destructive of these ends, it is the Right of the People to alter or to abolish it, and to institute new Government, laying its foundation on such principles, and organizing its powers in such form, as to them shall seem most likely to effect their Safety and Happiness.

Source: Hobbes’s Moral and Political Philosophy, SEP 2022. Graphic: AI generated.

Journalism–BuzzFeed 2017

On January 10, 2017, ten days before Donald Trump’s inauguration as the 45th President of the United States, BuzzFeed News published an unverified, salacious dossier compiled by Christopher Steele, a former British intelligence officer, suggesting that Russia had compromising evidence on the future President.

The dossier’s claims, laughable and fictional to any objective reporter, included graphic instances of abhorrent sexual behavior and treasonous activity. BuzzFeed supposedly attempted to verify or falsify any of the claims but was unable to do so. They published the dossier anyway.

On January 5, 2017, U.S. Intelligence, including James Comey, John Brennan, Mike Rogers, and James Clapper, briefed Obama on the contents of the dossier. The next day, likely on Obama’s orders, the same intelligence chiefs briefed Trump in New York. Trump later claimed that he thought the intelligence chiefs, mainly Comey, were trying to blackmail him. Comey knew at the time that the Democrats had funded the dossier but felt that information was immaterial to the discussion with Trump.

After much gnashing of teeth and rending of clothes concerning Trump’s alleged misdeeds by the mainstream media, it eventually came out that the Steele dossier was a complete fiction, although Steele to this day maintains its accuracy. It was bought and paid for by the 2016 Hillary Clinton presidential campaign and the Democratic National Committee. The dossier funding was brokered by the Democratic lawyer Marc Elias, who at the time was working for the Clinton campaign, through the law firm Perkins Coie. This firm then hired Fusion GPS, which in turn hired Christopher Steele to compile the dossier.

After the BuzzFeed publication, Trump responded a few hours later on X as shown in the attached graphic, calling it nothing but fake news.

Trivia: In May 2024, Vivek Ramaswamy paid $3.3 million for a small interest in BuzzFeed, attempting to steer its content to the right. His interest is too small to affect any change.

Source: These Reports Allege Trump Has Deep Ties to Russia by Bensinger, Elder, and Schoofs, 10 January 2017, BuzzFeed. Graphic: X Response from Trump, 2017.

Who Knew

Researchers from the University of Birmingham and two other UK schools provide long-suspected evidence that glaciers near volcanoes move along the surface approximately 50% quicker than the average glacier.

The researchers write in the journal Communications Earth & Environment that, “Specifically, proximity to volcanoes most likely means higher volcanic geothermal flux or heat, which in turn triggers enhanced subglacial melt, increased basal water pressures, sliding, and ice flow.” In other words, a thin layer of water between the glacier and the warm ground acts as a lubricant, allowing the glacier to move faster.

The authors of the paper believe that monitoring the velocity of glaciers would prove to be a useful tool to assess imminent volcanic hazards. Left unsaid in the paper is that increased movement of glaciers may point to a natural process that is not related to climate change.

Trivia: One percent of the planet’s 214,086 glaciers are found within 3 miles (5 km) of an active volcano.

Source: Proximity to Active Volcanoes Enhances Glacier Velocity by Mallalieu et al, CE&E 2024.  Graphic: Antarctic Glacier.

The Natural State of Man

Robert Howard, 20th-century pulp fiction author and creator of Conan the Barbarian, believed that “barbarianism is the natural state of mankind. Civilization is unnatural. It is the whim of circumstance.”

Thomas Hobbes, 17th-century English philosopher best known for his social contract theory, attempted to justify that the authority of the state superseded the rights of man, believing that the natural state of man was war, that life was “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short,” thus necessitating some higher authority to calm and tame the natural instincts of man.

Michael Huemer, professor of philosophy at UC Boulder, argues that “The current state of American society is a historical fluke, marked by extraordinarily low levels of exploitation, oppression, and injustice… The key sources of this happy state include such institutions as democracy, free markets, and modern science.”

I would add free speech coupled with property rights to the mix. Modern science is a double-edged sword that in the end, I would argue, is more a societal neutral force rather than a force against our true nature.

Huemer further maintains that before we tear down these stabilizing institutions, we should heed the advice of the Hippocratic Oath and first do no harm, stating, “If we undermine our current norms and institutions, the most likely result is not that we will be swept into a paradise… [but] the most likely result is that we will revert to something closer to the natural state of human beings.”

Huemer concludes with the observation that the 20th-century experiment called communism swept away all existing culture, norms, and institutions, resulting in 100 million deaths.

Source: Oxford Reference. Progressive Myths by M. Huemer, 2024. Graphic: Conan, Kindle Book Cover, Amazon.

Lighter Fare

Monster Summer: Martha’s Vineyard of the 90s, a summer haven for kids of all ages having fun until a zombie virus begins to infect Noah’s (Thames) friends, draining their spirits down to their souls. Noah, suspecting foul play, recruits the town’s curmudgeon, Gene (Gibson), a retired detective, to help solve the mystery.

Monster Summer, not far removed from the 2006 animated Monster House, shows that facing one’s fears are better than hiding from the unknown and, in the process, discovering friendships that will last a lifetime.

The movie is a children’s film that requires a kid’s heart and a warm spot for Mel Gibson’s irreverent humor and unfortunate script to fully enjoy, even for the old and grey.

Genre: Adventure—Kids–Suspense

Directed by: David Henri

Screenplay by: Cornelius Uliano, Bryan Schulz

Music by: Frederik Wiedmann

Cast: Mason Thames, Mel Gibson

Film Location: North Carolina, USA

ElsBob: 6.5/10

IMDb: 5.8/10

Rotten Tomatoes Critics: 59%

Rotten Tomatoes Popcornmeter: 84%

Metacritic Metascore: 53%

Metacritic User Score: -/10

Theaters: 4 October 2024

Runtime: 97 minutes  

Source: Rotten Tomatoes, IMDb, Metacritic.Graphic: Monster Summer Movie Poster, copyright Pastime Pictures.

Tenute Neirano Tirteo Barbera D’Asti Superiore 2021

Barbera from Asti, Piedmont, Italy

Purchase Price: $13.98

James Suckling 90, ElsBob 91

ABV: 14.0%

Aromas of raspberries and spices, medium to full-bodied, with amplified acidity, and dry. This wine will complement just about any food from steaks to pizza to cheese. Enjoy.

An excellent wine at less than half the price you would expect to pay for a comparable wine.

Trivia: The Italian Piedmont region is where Hannibal initially descended from the Alps with his elephants to engage the Romans in the Second Punic War, which spanned the period from 218-201 BC.

Stax Country:

The words Stax and country, seldom found in the vicinity of each other, come together for an emotional tour de force of soulful ballads, evoking the passions of love, heartache, and life like an old photo album that chronicles a simpler, happier time.

Jared Boyd, writing for Stax, comments that “Stax Country illuminates these varied voices along a Venn diagram of soul and country, underscoring the label’s ambition to break new ground… This compilation is a testament to Stax’s pioneering spirit and support for musical diversity, highlighting an era when soulful storytelling found common ground with country’s honesty and zeal.

Originally released in 2017, the album was remastered and reissued in October 2024 with sound quality as crisp and clear as a nightingale’s melody waking you on a Saturday morning. Stax excellence shines through in this compilation of lost gems.

Source: Stax. Graphic: Album Cover with Sweet Country Music by Becki Bluefield.

Soulless

MIT researchers found that Large Language Models (LLMs), although able to output impressive results without internal understanding of the data they manipulate, were unable to cope with small modifications to their data sets.

The researchers discovered that an LLM could provide correct driving directions in New York City while lacking an accurate internal map of the city. When they took a detailed look under the LLM’s hood, they saw a map of NYC that included many nonexistent streets superimposed on the real grid. Despite this poor understanding of actual streets, the model could still provide perfect directions for navigating the city—a fascinating “generative garbage within, Michelangelo out” concept.

In a further twist, when the researchers closed off a few actual streets, the LLM’s performance degraded rapidly because it was still relying on the nonexistent streets and was unable to adapt to the changes.

Source: MIT. “Despite Its Impressive Output, Generative AI Doesn’t Have a Coherent Understanding of the World.” ScienceDaily, 2024.  Graphic: AI istock.

FDR Wins 4th Term

On Tuesday, 7 November 1944, Franklin D. Roosevelt won his fourth term as President of the United States, defeating Republican Thomas E. Dewey of New York.

Few states in the 1944 election had a primary system in place to vote for party nominees, instead choosing delegates to the national nominating convention through party caucuses or state conventions. The real job of selecting the party’s nominees occurred at the national conventions with little to no input from the voting public.

Democrats, concerned that Roosevelt might not live to complete his term, replaced the sitting left-wing and economically illiterate Vice President Henry A. Wallace with the Missouri Senator Harry S. Truman.

Roosevelt died on 12 April 1945, less than three months into his new term, with Truman assuming the presidency that same day.

Truman ordered the dropping of the first atomic bomb on Hiroshima on August 6, 1945, less than six months into his presidency, proving that holding the highest office in the land is fraught with uncertainty and requires unimaginable determination and strength.

Graphic: Electoral College Results for the 1944 Presidential Election.

No Art–No Merit

The Substance: Elisabeth Sparkle (Demi Moore), an ageing actor seeking to revive her career and her looks, along with reclaiming her fans, chooses poorly. Excessive gore and asininities ensue.

The movie explores themes of lost youth, the loneliness of fan forgetfulness, and mortality. The film attempts to find something new to say in re-imaging the 1992 movie: ‘Death Becomes Her’ starring Goldie Hawn, Meryl Streep, and Bruce Willis; but comes up with naught—nothing approaching sense or sensibility—just blood and guts substituting for substance.

Genre: Black Humor–Horror

Directed by: Corallie Fargeat

Screenplay by: Corallie Fargeat

Music by: Raffertie

Cast: Demi Moore, Margaret Qualley, Dennis Quaid

Film Location: France

ElsBob: 3.0/10

IMDb: 7.5/10

Rotten Tomatoes Critics: 90%

Rotten Tomatoes Popcornmeter: 74%

Metacritic Metascore: 78%

Metacritic User Score: 7.4/10

Theaters: 20 September 2024

Runtime: 141 minutes

Budget: $17.5 million

Box Office: $43.3 million

Source: Rotten Tomatoes, IMDb, Metacritic.Graphic: The Substance Movie Poster, copyright Mubi.